Originally Posted On June 10, 2023 and Last Updated On October 26, 2023

Disclaimer: We independently review everything we recommend. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. You can learn more here.

The BEST Jello Shot Cups (Plus Buyer’s Guide)

You wouldn’t think it, but there are actually a lot of considerations when you’re looking to buy the best jello shot cups or containers. So even though it might be a really boring topic, we decided to write you this guide anyway on buying the best cups for jello shots.

First, you have size. Do you want one ounce or two ounce shots? Do you want paper or plastic jello shot cups? Do you need jello shot cups with lids? Do you want colored or clear? Or do you just want the cheapest shot cups and move on…

One thing I’d like to point out is that if you’re using these to make 100 Jell-O shots for a party or plan on not re-using these for more shooters or something else, then I highly suggest either using paper or biodegradable cups for your party.

There’s no reason to create more waste that’ll sit in a landfill for the next thousand years.

So, having thrown far too many parties as well as owning a bar, I think I can give you a really good breakdown as to what you should and shouldn’t buy when it comes to purchasing cups for jello shots.

Our Top Picks!

Compostable Biobased Plastic Cups and Lids

These are Compostable Biobased Plastic Cups and Lids for the most environmentally friendly option and are manufactured by Outside the Box Papers. I really do suggest these as my number one pick as little plastic cups can float in oceans for years and create havoc on the environment. So get these and feel good not only doing your shots, but throwing away the container as well.

Buy Now

Crystalware 2oz. Plastic Cups Without Lids

These are really well made brand name cups by Crystalware. They come in all different sizes, so you have option there. These don’t have lids, and unless you’re transporting your shots, I suggest not buying cups with lids as the lids are just going to end up in the trash can as well. So a little less waste with these. And they’re pretty cheap.

Buy Now

Comfy Package Cups With Lids

These are perfect if you need lids for transport or you plan on stacking these somewhere. They come in all different sizes and they’re made from durable crack-resistant polypropylene, so they won’t shatter when you squeeze your shots! The 1 ounce cups come in packs of 100 for $5.99!

Buy Now

WELLIFE 200 Pack Gold Glitter Cups

These hard plastic containers are super elegant and BPA free plastic. They are reusable and make your shots look a little more “Upscale”, perfect for weddings and anniversaries. These come in packs of 200 and equal one ounce. Perfect for large events. And economically priced.

Buy Now

Silver Glitter Square Cups with Spoons

When you don’t want to tongue out your shot, these make the perfect “upscale” shot container. And they come with a matching spoon! Each pack has 100 spoons and cups and goes for around $20, so everyone can simply scoop out their shots and never have to deal with jello sticking to the sides of their cup.

Buy Now

Oomcu Square Clear Plastic Cups plus Spoons!

Another square cup with matching spoons, only this time these cups aren’t quite as fancy as the number 4 pick. Rather these are made to show off the shot and are completely clear. They’re also durable so you can even wash these and reuse them. And come with matching spoons. They’re hard plastic so they can’t be “squeezed” and must be eaten with their spoons.

Buy Now

Zappy Elegant Clear Slanted Cylinder Cups

These are perfect for any layered shot recipes you might want to try. They are perfectly clear and on the fancy side if you’re trying to impress your friends. The only problem with these is that you can’t squeeze them, they are only meant to be used with their provided spoons. 2.5 oz cups in 25 count.

Buy Now

EZ-Inject Jello Shot Syringes

No list would be complete without including jello shot syringes. These are reusable and are specifically made for Jello. This product comes with 25 one and a half ounce (1.5 oz) syringes and a handy rack to keep them in. You can buy Jell-o Shot syringes either from Amazon or most specialty stores. They’re made of premium food grade BPA-free plastic and are dishwasher safe.

Buy Now

Zappy’s Mini Martini Glasses!

These little guys mimic martini glasses and look really cute. I like these because getting your whole shot out is easier than narrower cups plus they’re clear so you can use them for layered shots. You’ll need to use your tongue as these are hard plastic, but they work well. These 2 ounce cups are reusable and come in packs of 40.

Buy Now

What Size Should I Use?

First, let’s talk about size. Size does matter here 🙂 Both in amount consumed and price per cup.

The standard shot sizes for the usual throw away jello shot cups are one ounce and two ounces. And these cups follow this measurement.

Deciding which size to choose is more of a personal preference and anything else. But most people go with 2 ounces. And I suggest you do the same unless you’re creating your Jell-O shot masterpieces for a children’s party, then you can go with the small jello shot cups.

The next point I want to hit has to do about being environmentally friendly. When it comes to choosing paper or plastic, it’s the same old debate as choosing which bags to use a supermarket as there is for jello shots containers.

Personally I just use the cheap paper ones when I’m making a ton of shots for family and friends, but I do grab the biodegradable ones now. They only cost like a penny more, and now that I’m not a broke college kid any longer, I’ll pay the extra penny to feel good about destroying my body, but not the environment.

But if I’m trying to be artistic, and I want to layer my Jell-O shots, then I use the clear plastic ones with a little give.

Again, it really depends on what you’re using these for. If you’re just making Jell-O shots for some frat party, nobody’s going to care what the shot actually looks like.

All they’re going to care about is getting ripped (drunk). So the paper cups are not only cheap, but also super easy to dispose of. And they’re biodegradable!

On the other hand if you’re creating artisan Jell-O shots that are three layers deep in a festive color combination to impress your friends with your upscale drink making capabilities, then you’re going to want people to see your artistic abilities. That’s when the clear Jell-O shop cups come in.

One last thing to consider is if you’re going to need lids for your shots. Don’t forget, if you’re planning on traveling with your Jell-O shots, you need some way to keep the Jell-O in the cup.

There are two easy with fixes for this. The first one is if you have a good sized baking sheet or an actual commercial baking sheet, you can just use the paper cups and then use Saran Wrap to cover them up. It works and it’s cheap and easy.

The second one is you really care about how your shots look aesthetically, then you just going to want to go with the plastic jello shot cups with lids. It really is the best option as far as storage and are basic bar tools.

Okay, so I’ve given you some things to think about when it comes to buying Jell-O shot cups. It’s not rocket science, but there are a few considerations to finding the best container for jello shots.

Now hopefully you know what you’re using the cups for. So now it’s time to move on and figure out which option is the best to buy for what you’re going for.

Comparison Table

*This table includes the price, material, capacity, additional features, and expert reviews for each type of jello shot cup.

What Types are there?

There are primarily 3 types of jello shot cups not counting things like jello shot syringes or using fruit skins as the cup. You have paper, plastic and reusable containers. And then there are alternatives like lids, clear, or biodegradable. I’ll go over the differences between cups so you can decide what’s best for you and your party goers.

Paper Jello Shot Cups

So let’s start with the easiest. Paper jello shot cups may be one of the more environmentally friendly options out there, but they are not always the most practical.

There are plenty of pros to them. They’re super cheap, they’re disposable so no mess to contend with, and you can usually get a hold of them pretty easily.

The main disadvantage with paper cups is that they can leak, leaving your fridge a mess and your cups rather soggy when it comes time to shoot your shooters. One tip here is to let your mixture cool a bit before pouring them into paper or even the biodegradable containers.

And when it comes to eating the actual shot out of one of these, you pretty much have to squeeze out whatever you can while hopefully not breaking the bottom out of your cup. Or licking the sides where the jello sticks between the cracks where the paper folds.

Compostable Jello Shot Cups

I love these cups and they are my number one pick for paper category because they are actually made from plant based “paper”, but act more like a plastic cup.

The one thing to note about these is that since they are plant based paper, they do NOT stand up to heat as well as an oil based plastic would. So you must let your Jell-O cool in the pan before pouring the mixture into these containers.

That goes for all of the biodegradable options I’ve listed. They will melt if the Jello is too hot!

And even though you might be able to more easily recycle paper, it’s not such an Earth friendly option if the paper cup is still covered in jello, which is likely to be the case. Plus these sorts of containers usually have some kind of plastic or wax coating to try to make them as waterproof as possible.

So they may not always be 100% Earth friendly. But if you do care about the environment, if you’re making my 100 jello shot recipe, these would be the ones to use.

Usually though, they won’t be recycled at all. But at least these cups will break down over time in your local dump, so for the environmentally friendly drinkers out there, this is your best option if you’re looking to throw them away.

One tip when using paper Jell-O shot cups. Try to use them as soon as possible. Don’t let the Jell-O sit in them too long. The longer the Jell-O sits inside the cups, the more they will stick to the paper. So the best case scenario would be to make your jello shots in the afternoon and use them that night one the Jell-O sets up.

TIP: Spray a very small amount of an aerosol oil like Pam into each cup. You won’t taste it and it’ll really help keeping these cups non-stick. Check you didn’t spray too much and it collects in the bottom. If so, just use a paper towel to get out any excess oil.

Plastic Jell-O Shot Cups with Lids

The obvious advantage to using plastic cups with lids is that they are plastic and therefore won’t leak and that they have optional matching lids which helps them stay fresh and make them easy to store and transport.

It’s one thing to make them in your kitchen, another to get them to where the party is.

But where these cups really stand out is that most plastic cups are completely see-through which means you can make some really beautiful Halloween or Christmas shots using the festive colored appropriate Jell-O and your shots will end up looking beautiful enough to be the centerpiece of your party. Who doesn’t love a little color, right?

And of course these cups come in both 1 ounce or 2 ounce varieties. And the cost is minimal.

Some not only that, there usually sold either with lids or without them. So if you don’t need him, you can even save a few pennies more and lessen the load on the environment.

And of course there’s always a few cons. The biggest disadvantage for the average jello shots containers is that there are the really cheap brittle kind and easily broken plastic. So when you try to squeeze out the Jell-O, you sometimes just end up breaking up the cup in making a bigger mess than anything else.

So be sure you’re getting a plastic that is pliable and not brittle. The idea with a jello shot is that you should be able to squeeze the shot out of the cup a little to get it started.

Now if kids are involved (obviously we are talking non-alcoholic shots), you might want to just give them spoons as well. Or use Jello shot syringes instead.

EZ-Squeeze™

These cups were definitely a great idea. The company actually makes products specifically for jello shots. And nice EZ jello shots and easy to squeeze cups are perfect!

But… truth is, these things don’t stand up the way you think they would. So here’s my quick overview…

Pros: These cups have some pros for sure. They are cheap, they don’t leak and according to their manufacture, they help shorten the chill time of your shots setting up. They also really do allow you to shoot your shot more easily than say the paper cups do.

But one caveat as far as the pros, when I made my jello shots, I didn’t notice any noticeable difference on the time it took for my shots to be ready. But maybe they do shave off a few seconds, I really couldn’t “scientifically” say.

The Cons: They’re plastic, so if you’re environmentally friendly, you won’t want these.

Also, although they are plastic, they really don’t hold their shape after you use them. This is because of the squeezing you do. It deforms the cups shape and they will never return to their natural state!

And forget the lids. They really don’t fit that well. even before you squeeze them!

AND you still end up licking the sides of the cup just like any of the cheaper cups. although if you use the sugar-free Jell-O, for some reason it seems to stick less.

So my biggest negative is that they are plastic, yet they aren’t reusable. So what’s the point???

The regular plastic cups with lids are better, cheaper and if you are making layered shots, look a lot more stunning as these are a bit “foggy” as far as the see through plastic goes.

FAQ

Conclusion

So there you have it. A complete buyers guide to Jell-O shot cups. I’ve tried to make sure everything you could possibly want to know about them was included so that you could make an easy buying decision.

And don’t forget to take a look at my article: How to Make Jello Shots!

Find out where to buy Jello Shot Cups here.

And if you think I left anything out, please feel free to comment below and I’ll add it to the article.